In short
Choose a helmet-mounted headlamp with a wide, even flood for moving through the cave and a spot for shafts and big chambers; enough runtime on the setting you will really use for your longest trip, with margin; waterproofing of IPX7 or better; batteries you can recharge or swap reliably; and controls you can work with muddy gloves. Then carry independent back-up lights: American cavers recommend three sources of light per person.
Beam pattern matters more than lumens
Lumens measure the total light a lamp gives out; candela measures how intense the brightest part of the beam is. Two lamps with the same lumens behave very differently: a high candela figure means a concentrated beam that reaches far, a lower one with the same lumens means a wider beam that lights more around you. Beams of about 20 degrees or more are usually called floods; a hotspot of a few degrees is a spot.
Underground you spend most of the time looking at things a few metres away: the floor you step on, the walls you squeeze past, the roof above your head. A wide, even flood serves that best, and it keeps your peripheral vision working (see the tunnel effect). A spot is for looking up a shaft or across a chamber. The best caving lights offer both, ideally at the same time.
Runtime: read the small print
Under the ANSI/PLATO FL1 standard, runtime is measured until the light falls to 10% of its output 30 seconds after switching on. Some headlamp makers rate it instead until the light falls to 1 lux at 2 metres, which gives longer numbers that cannot be compared with FL1.
Look at the runtime of the setting you will actually use, not the lowest one, and at how the output behaves: a regulated lamp holds its brightness and then drops sharply, an unregulated one dims steadily. Plan for your longest trip plus a wide margin: getting stuck behind rising water or helping a slow partner can double the time underground.
Batteries you can trust underground
There is nowhere to charge in a cave. Rechargeable lithium-ion packs give the most light for their weight; lamps that take standard cells let you carry spares and swap them in the dark. Whatever you choose, know how full your battery is before you go in, and carry spare power for your main light as well as separate back-up lights.
Water and mud
Caves are wet: drips, streams, pools and sumps. The IP code tells you how much water a lamp withstands. IPX4 only means splashes; IPX7 means it survives immersion in 1 metre of fresh water for 30 minutes; IPX8 means more than that, to a depth and time the maker states. An IPX8 rating under FL1 is not a dive rating: it is tested by checking the lamp works after immersion, not during it.
Mud is the other enemy. Prefer sealed switches, battery covers you can open with cold hands and clean easily, and a lens that is easy to wipe.
Mounting and controls
Cavers wear their main light on the helmet to keep both hands free, and usually a second light on the helmet too, so they can switch over at once if the first fails. Look for a mount that holds the lamp firmly when you crawl and bump the roof, an angle you can adjust, and buttons big enough to use with gloves. A lock-out stops the lamp from switching itself on in your bag.
Back-up lights are not optional
Light failing is one of the classic ways cave rescues begin. American cavers recommend at least three independent sources of light per person, while two is common practice among European cavers; the US National Park Service asks for four reliable lights per person in its caves. Spain's cave rescue groups also tell cavers to carry spare lighting and batteries. See how to start caving for the rest of the safety basics.
Colour and red light
A light with good colour rendering (a high CRI) and a neutral white makes it easier to read rock, mud and water, and to see the colours of formations. A red mode is useful at rest stops and in camp: the rods, the cells of night vision, are insensitive to red, so red light lets your eyes stay adapted to the dark.
A checklist before you buy
Before choosing, check that your headlamp has:
- A wide, even flood for moving, and a spot for reach
- Runtime on your usual setting that covers your longest trip with margin
- A clear way to see how much battery is left
- IPX7 or better, with sealed switches
- A secure helmet mount and buttons you can use with gloves
- A lock-out against switching on in the bag
- Room on the helmet for a back-up light, plus a third light in your pack
Questions and answers
- How many lumens do I need for caving?
- There is no single number. How the light is spread matters as much as how much there is: a wide, even flood lights the passage around you, while a high-candela spot gives reach for shafts and large chambers. Bigger caves call for more light and more reach.
- Can I use a running or hiking headlamp for caving?
- For a guided visit to a show cave, yes. For real caving it should be waterproof (IPX7 or better), last your whole trip with margin, fit firmly on a helmet, and be one of at least two or three independent lights you carry.
- Is IPX4 enough for caving?
- No. IPX4 only covers splashing water. Caves have streams, pools and sometimes sumps, so look for IPX7 (immersion to 1 metre for 30 minutes) or IPX8.
- Should my caving headlamp have a spot or a flood beam?
- Both. A flood is what you use most of the time to move safely, because it lights your whole field of view; a spot is for seeing far up shafts or across big chambers.
- Does Carbi make a caving headlamp?
- Carbi was born among cavers, and the new Carbi headlamp is in development. Its specifications will be published when they are final; join the waitlist to hear first.
Keep reading
Sources
- Wikipedia: Flashlight – the ANSI/PLATO FL1 standard
- Wikipedia: IP code
- Wikipedia: Caving
- Wikipedia: Headlamp (outdoor)
- US National Park Service – Ozark National Scenic Riverways: cave safety
- Federación Aragonesa de Espeleología – Espeleo Socorro Aragonés: prevención y accidentes
- Wikipedia: Adaptation (eye)
- Wikipedia: Color rendering index