What is remote phosphor in LED lighting?

By Pedro Albaladejo · Published

In short

Most white LEDs are a blue LED chip coated with a yellow phosphor: the phosphor turns part of the blue light into yellow, and the mix looks white. In a remote phosphor design the phosphor is not on the chip but on a separate piece, such as a plate, dome or diffuser, some distance away and lit by blue LEDs. The result is a larger glowing surface that gives a softer, more diffuse light.

How a white LED makes white light

LED chips give out light of one colour. White LEDs are usually blue indium gallium nitride (InGaN) chips with a phosphor on top, most often cerium-doped yttrium aluminium garnet (YAG:Ce). The phosphor absorbs part of the blue light and gives out a broad band from green to red, mostly yellow; that yellow plus the remaining blue is seen as white.

Changing the phosphor changes the light: different mixes give a warmer or cooler white and better or worse colour rendering. The LEDs with the best colour rendering use a mix of phosphors, at some cost in efficiency.

Remote phosphor: moving the phosphor away from the chip

In most LEDs the phosphor sits right on the chip. In a remote phosphor design it is coated onto a separate, preformed piece, often polycarbonate, placed at a distance from blue LEDs. The light you see comes from that whole coated surface rather than from a tiny bright point.

Remote phosphors give a more diffuse light, which is wanted in many lamps and fittings, and the design is more tolerant of small variations in the colour of the blue LEDs.

What it is good at, and its trade-offs

A large, evenly glowing surface is easy on the eyes: there is no tiny, intense point to cause glare, and it lights a wide area evenly. That makes remote phosphor attractive wherever a soft, wide light is wanted.

The other side is optics. How tightly light can be focused depends on how big its source is (a property called étendue), so a large glowing surface cannot be squeezed into a long, narrow beam the way a tiny LED chip can. For reach you still need a small, bright emitter and a lens or reflector. That is why most lights that must reach far use conventional LEDs, and why a remote phosphor is a flood, not a spot.

Remote phosphor and the tunnel effect

Because it spreads light widely and evenly, a remote phosphor flood is one way to fight the tunnel effect of headlamps, where a bright hotspot leaves your surroundings in the dark. It is close in spirit to the broad light of the old carbide lamp.

Archive: Carbi's first prototype (2018–2020). Not the new model.

Carbi's first prototype

Carbi's first prototype, presented in 2018–2020, used a remote phosphor element for its flood light and a conventional LED for its spot, to give cavers a wide, even light with the efficiency of LEDs. That is the prototype's story; the new Carbi is being developed, and its technology and specifications will be published when they are final.

Questions and answers

What is remote phosphor?
A way of making white LED light in which the phosphor that turns blue light into white is placed on a separate piece at a distance from the LED chips, instead of directly on them. It gives a larger, softer, more diffuse source of light.
Is remote phosphor the same as a COB LED?
No. In a chip-on-board (COB) LED, many chips sit close together under a phosphor layer applied directly over them. In a remote phosphor design the phosphor is on a separate part, away from the chips.
Why don't more headlamps use remote phosphor?
Mainly size and reach. A large glowing surface cannot be focused into a long, narrow beam, so lamps that need to reach far use small LED chips with a lens or reflector. Remote phosphor suits wide, even flood light.
Does remote phosphor give better colour?
It depends on the phosphor used. Colour rendering comes from the phosphor mix, whether the phosphor is on the chip or remote; mixes with the best colour rendering trade a little efficiency for it.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Light-emitting diode
  2. Wikipedia: Phosphor
  3. Wikipedia: Étendue
  4. Wikipedia: Glare (vision)
  5. Wikipedia: Color rendering index

Be the first to know when Carbi launches

A headlamp designed around peripheral vision, born in caving. Join the waitlist and we will write when it is ready.

We respect your privacy